You’ve probably never asked yourself that question, but it’s not as silly as it sounds. Think about it for a minute. How do you explain the fact that you aren’t constantly surprised by the wide variety of events, situations, and reactions you encounter?
The answer to that question also explains why it can’t possibly be true that “you always have a choice.”
Your brain is predictive, rather than reactive.
Until fairly recently, the commonly held belief was that the brain merely reacted to sensations it picked up, primarily from the outside world. The idea was that many of the brain’s neurons were dormant most of the time until they were stimulated by a sight or a sound.
But that is not the case. Neurons are constantly firing, interacting and stimulating each other at various rates. According to Lisa Feldman Barrett, University Distinguished Professor of Psychology at Northeastern University:
This brain activity represents millions of predictions of what you will encounter next in the world, based on your lifetime of past experience.
Your reactions are your body adjusting to the predictions your brain makes based on the state your body was in the last time it was in a similar situation.
Your brain is trying to put together thoughts, feelings, and perceptions so they arrive as needed, not a second afterward.
This activity does not take place at the conscious (System 2) level, but at the unconscious (System 1) level, which processes 11 million bits of information at a time. What you become aware of (thoughts, feelings, impulses, etc.) are the results of this unconscious processing. And you’re only aware of what your brain thinks you need to know, when you need to know it.
Furthermore, according to an article by a trio of neuroscientists published in Frontiers in Psychology:
Your brain generates multiple possible representations of what to expect in the environment. The representation with the smallest prediction error is selected.
However the generation of representations is constrained by what is stored in memory and by the sampling of the environment.
Another way to think about it is that these representations of what to expect are constrained by your mental model (see: Are You Thinking Outside the Box Yet?). Your brain constantly updates your mental model based on the accuracy of its predictions—as well as on its own agenda. Again, this occurs outside your conscious awareness.
Barrett provides this example:
You’re interacting with a friend and, based on context, your brain predicts that she will smile. This prediction drives your motor neurons to move your mouth in advance to smile back, and your movement causes your friend’s brain to issue new predictions and actions, back and forth, in a dance of prediction and action. If predictions are wrong, your brain has mechanisms to correct them and issue new ones.
The unconscious part of the brain is always several steps ahead of the conscious part. As both Barrett and neuroscientist David Eagleman have pointed out, this is what makes activities such as sports possible. If the brain was reactive, rather than predictive, it wouldn’t operate fast enough to enable you to hit a baseball or block a goal.
A merely reactive brain wouldn’t have helped Michael Phelps win his 10th gold medal while swimming blind as a result of his goggles filling with water. All of his previous practice, experience, and knowledge gave his brain a solid basis for predicting what he needed to do in order to win. Pretty amazing.
Because your brain is predictive:
- You are not constantly surprised.
- You don’t always have a choice.
- You are able to engage in activities that require quick and accurate responses.
- You are capable of learning from your experiences.
- You don’t have to think about every little thing you do in the course of a day.
- You find it difficult to change undesirable habits.
- You may be tricked by various types of illusions.
- You are unaware of your visual blind spot.
Our primary contact with the world, all this suggests, is via our expectations about what we are about to see or experience. —Andy Clark, philosopher and cognitive scientist, University of Edinburgh
When you are surprised, it’s because your brain encounters unpredictable stimuli: something other than what it expected. Unpredictable stimuli require conscious (System 2) processing. To get a sense of this in action, take note of the occasions when you experience surprise and try to compare your actual experience to the experience your brain might have been expecting.
The fact that you are not, in fact, constantly surprised means that your brain is pretty darn good at making predictions the vast majority of the time.