Consider these two groups of people.
One group (Group A) believes that reasons are real and that reasons cause things to happen or not happen.
The other group (Group B) believes that invisible intentional agents are real and that invisible intentional agents cause things to happen or not happen.
What’s the difference between these two groups?
- Both Group A and Group B are very confident in their beliefs. But the degree of confidence we have about what we think or believe has no correlation with the accuracy or reality of the thought or belief.
- Neither Group A nor Group B can produce a tangible example of a reason or of an invisible intentional agent because both are figments of the imagination.
- Whether reasons or invisible intentional agents are causing things to happen or not happen, the people in either group are not responsible.
- As a result, the people in both groups have very little power to make things happen or to prevent things from happening.
- Meanwhile, the people in Group B are busy (wasting time, effort, and energy) trying to fight off or appease invisible intentional agents, and the people in Group A are busy (wasting time, effort, and energy) first turning the events, situations, encounters, circumstances, and conditions of their lives into reasons—and then trying to address the problems they perceive to be the result of the reasons they have created!
Each group also feels superior to the other group. If you believe in reasons you’re much more likely to be seen as sane—even reasonable—by others. But it makes absolutely no difference whether you believe in reasons or you believe in invisible intentional agents. The bottom line is that something else—not you—is running your life.